Newsletter

What publishers can learn from a subscriber who built her own news bot

We look at how easier discovery, personalisation and useful briefings can help publishers build apps that fit readers’ daily routines.

Easier discovery, relevant updates and a quick catch-up can help make a news app part of readers’ daily routines.

At INMA’s Media Tech & AI Week in San Francisco, Julie Young spoke about why she had built her own AI news tool. A start-up founder, former Snapchat user researcher and paying FT subscriber, she had grown frustrated with finding her way around the FT’s website. As INMA’s account of the session explains, her tool brings together reporting from several sources and organises it around her interests.

Julie had already done the thing publishers work so hard to encourage. She had paid for a subscription. But she still felt the need to build something herself to make it fit her day. The features she wanted, such as following interests, reading summaries and finding the full story easily are all things publishers could make simpler within their own products.

At Pugpig, we see an opportunity for publishers to meet those needs within their own apps. Making the journalism easier to find and use gives readers a reason to return, rather than leaving them to look elsewhere for a better experience. In this week’s Media Bulletin, we explore what publishers can learn from Julie’s experience.


A reader who redesigned their news routine

Julie was paying for the FT’s journalism but struggling with the experience of reading it. Labels such as “myFT” were confusing, she kept being logged out and finding the stories she wanted took too much effort.

So she built a bot that organises reporting around her chosen interests, provides summaries and lets her explore further. It also brings in material from Substacks and selected blogs. She still clicks through to read around two articles in full each day, but now relies on her bot for most of her FT reading. She says she would cancel her subscription if the FT blocked it.

Julie clearly values the FT’s journalism. She’s paying for it and wants to keep reading it, but has built her own way around an experience she finds frustrating to use.

Of course, most subscribers won’t build their own bot, and no single publisher could offer everything Julie’s tool does, including bringing different publications together. But the frustrations that led her to build it are worth exploring.

It helps to think about what readers want at different points in their day. Someone catching up before work needs a different experience from someone settling down with a long investigation. Both might value the same subscription, but a single feed of articles won’t necessarily meet their different needs.

Start by fixing the basics

It is tempting to see Julie’s bot and immediately ask whether it is solved by deploying an AI assistant. However, her issues suggest some more basic work deserves attention first. Readers need to be able to find their way around, stay signed in and understand what features do. Following a topic or finding a saved article should be intuitive.

At Pugpig, we encourage publishers to look closely at how easily readers can find what they want in their apps. Are navigation labels clear to someone outside the newsroom? Can readers find the subjects they care about without searching through several sections? Small frustrations can make good journalism feel harder to access than it should.

New features deserve the same care. Before adding a personalised feed, decide how readers will choose their interests, where the feed will appear and how they can update their choices. Pugpig Follow is built around those questions, placing a reader’s chosen topics, authors and teams in a dedicated feed rather than scattering them through the app. If you introduce article audio, make the play button easy to find and let readers continue browsing while they listen. Each feature should make a task easier, without leaving readers to work out how it fits into the app.

Make following an interest worthwhile

Julie’s experience shows how much effort it can take to find the stories that interest you, even within a publication you value. Publishers need to make relevant coverage easier to discover, rather than expecting readers to search for it on every visit. At WAN-IFRA’s Digital Media Europe in London last month, we heard how Ringier is tackling this at Blick. Its “Follow My Team” service gives sports fans a personalised feed and updates about their chosen team, bringing the coverage they want directly to them.

For publishers developing their apps, asking someone to select their interests needs to lead to a noticeable improvement in what they receive. A reader who follows a football team should not have to search through the sports section every time they want an update. Their team’s coverage should come to them.

The value comes from whether following something makes the next visit more useful. A personalised section hidden behind unfamiliar navigation is unlikely to do much for the reader.

Give the audience a reason to open the app

Blick gives sports fans a reason to return whenever they want to catch up on their team. Publishers can apply the same thinking to other moments in a reader’s day. A morning briefing could help readers catch up before work. An audio playlist could fit a commute. Push notifications based on followed topics could bring readers straight back to coverage they’re interested in.

Each gives readers a reason to return beyond simply checking for new articles. It also gives the product team something concrete to design around. A catch-up experience should help someone feel informed without requiring them to search through everything published since yesterday.

There is room for personal relevance and editorial judgement together. As we explored in our bulletin on personalisation in apps, publishers can combine reader-selected interests with editorially curated content. Following a subject should make it easier to find, without hiding important journalism outside those preferences.

The relationship between those experiences needs to be clear. Readers should understand where to find their followed topics and where to go for the editor’s selection. They should not have to work out why two apparently similar feeds contain different stories.

Let readers finish, but with room to explore

One of the attractions of Julie’s tool is that it lets her get “to zero” each day. She reaches the end, knows she is up to date and stops. That runs against much of how publishers judge success, where another click or a longer session usually counts as a win. But for a reader catching up before work, finishing is the point. Someone who completes a briefing and feels sufficiently informed has received exactly the value they wanted, and that sense of completion may be what brings them back the next day.

Content formats should accommodate both a defined catch-up and open-ended exploration. A briefing might offer a finite selection, with clear routes into full reporting, related analysis or audio for readers who have more time.

Summaries need a purpose within that experience. They might help readers decide which stories deserve closer attention or understand what has changed in a subject they already follow. Making every article shorter is not necessarily the answer.

Readers should be able to move easily from a summary to the full story. Someone with a few minutes might only want the briefing, while someone with more time can explore the reporting behind it.

Measure what brings readers back

If a briefing promises a quick catch-up, a longer session may mean the reader struggled to find what they needed rather than that they were more engaged. Completion, return visits and use of the routes into fuller reporting are better signs that it worked. The same applies to a personalised feed as opening it does not show that readers found it useful.

In practice, that means choosing a small number of measures for each experience. For a morning briefing, publishers might track the share of readers who reach the end, the share who tap through from at least one summary to the full story, and how many return the following morning. For a followed-topics feed, a better signal than opens is whether readers come back to it within a week and go on to read stories from it. A short in-app prompt asking whether the briefing left them feeling up to date can capture what the numbers miss. Over time, publishers can examine how these behaviours relate to renewal and cancellation, rather than assuming every interaction contributes equally.

A practical starting point is to choose one recurring reader task and improve the whole journey around it. That means checking discovery, navigation and login, making the benefit obvious, and asking readers whether the result meets their needs. A tightly defined experiment should teach more than launching several loosely connected features.

Julie’s willingness to cancel if the FT blocked her tool brings the argument back to what she values as a subscriber. The journalism matters to her, but so does being able to read it in a way that fits her day. Publishers can learn from her experience by understanding what readers are trying to do, where the existing product gets in their way and what would make it easier.

Julie went to considerable trouble to make journalism fit her day. Publishers can learn from the choices she made without assuming every reader wants a bot. Easier discovery, useful briefings and relevant updates are all reasons to invest in apps and other owned products. The task is to turn those capabilities into an experience readers understand, value and choose to return to.

Industry News

Here are some of the stories that caught our eye in the world of news and publishing recently.